An Islamic State (ISIS) commander was killed in Libya in mid-June, The Daily Beast reported yesterday, after being “paraded … through the streets amid the taunts of onlookers, and then walked … to a gallows, where he was hanged.” [SEE UPDATES] This occurred in the eastern city of Derna, long a hotbed of Islamic militancy. The crucial thing about the “executed” ISIS operative is that he was an Iraqi and an FRE—a former (Saddam) regime element—who had been dispatched to Libya last year to oversee the cultivation of an ISIS branch.
The Beast reported the slain ISIS jihadist as “Abu-Ali al-Anbari,” but this is almost certainly a mistake: the senior ISIS official with the nom de guerre Abu Ali al-Anbari is ISIS’ governor of Syria. The al-Anbari referred to is likely Abu Nabil al-Anbari, a former policeman in Saddam Hussein’s regime, who, according to CNN, had spent time with ISIS’ leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi in an American prison. If that is true, Abu Nabil must have been imprisoned between January 31 and December 6, 2004, because that’s the only time al-Baghdadi spent in an American jail. If Abu Nabil was arrested at this time, it underlines the point I made yesterday: the FREs within ISIS were Islamist fanatics before Saddam’s regime ended and joined ISIS early, when Abu Musab az-Zarqawi, the prince of the takfiris, was in command and “socialist infidels” (Ba’athists) were most unwelcome.
[UPDATE: In fact, Abu Nabil had been imprisoned by the U.S. in 2008 in Iraq. In prison, Abu Nabil was known as Abu Yazan al-Humairi. After about eighteen months, Abu Nabil was released, but shortly afterwards he was re-arrested. Abu Nabil was then broken out of Abu Ghraib prison on 21 July 2013 in an operation planned by Adnan al-Suwaydawi, who was also an FRE. Abu Nabil was soon appointed wali (governor) of Saladin Province, and had served as governor of another province before that. After the fall of Mosul on 10 June 2014, in an operation planned by Adnan al-Bilawi (another FRE), the Islamic State swept across central Iraq and it was Abu Nabil who led the operations in Saladin, specifically the towns of Samarra and Tikrit. A now-infamous ISIS video, “Upon the Prophetic Methodology,” released by al-Furqan on 28 July 2014, shows Abu Nabil rallying the troops in a two-minute speech on 5 June 2014 in preparation for the assault on Samarra. Another video from around the same time shows Abu Nabil conversing with local notables. In Tikrit, it was Abu Nabil who oversaw the genocidal anti-Shi’a massacre at Camp Speicher on 12 June 2014. When it was decided to expand ISIS into Libya, it was to Abu Nabil that they turned.]
By CNN’s reporting, Abu Nabil was in Libya in September 2014, in time to arrange the announcement of Wilayat Derna on October 3, 2014, a bay’a that was formally accepted by al-Baghdadi on November 13. Abu Nabil had put together the ISIS network in Libya by peeling away parts of al-Qaeda’s network, organized under the banner of Ansar al-Shari’a Libya (ASL), and by co-opting elements of the local criminal networks that were able to generate independent revenue.
There is a great amount of uncertainty around the degree of control that ISIS has over its branches or affiliates. In order for a branch to be accepted into the ISIS franchise, however, ISIS “central” in Syria/Iraq must have “full command and control” of the group’s media operations, according to Aaron Zelin.
It is no secret that propaganda has been important to ISIS and one of the things it has been important in doing is bringing in foreign fighters. Though the foreign fighters have very little military skill, they provide ISIS two key advantages. First, as Stalin put it, quantity has a quality all its own. Given that ISIS’ foreign fighters are attracted primarily by ideology, they are prepared to blow themselves up and throw themselves into individually-hopeless situations that nonetheless yield benefits for ISIS’ cause. Which is the second advantage: with no connection to the local population and driven primarily by religious devotion—expressed as obedience to ISIS’ commanders—the foreign recruits to ISIS will carry out orders for anti-civilian atrocities without the brakes of kin and custom that might afflict a local recruit. This helps ISIS maintain control in the areas it occupies by providing a believable stick to accompany its provision of carrots like order and social services. Having been part of an intelligence service trained by the KGB, the FREs have played a key part in ISIS’ propaganda output.
As I documented in February, Libya is the most promising ground for ISIS outside the Fertile Crescent—with Yemen and Egypt vying for second place—but one should be very careful about overstating ISIS’ expansion in Libya. The claims by ISIS to control important towns like Sirte and Derna keep being disproven. The claim to control Derna last October was found to be false in January; ISIS only controlled “some neighbourhoods“. And renewed claims of control in Derna were falsified in June when ISIS was kicked out of the town overnight, something that could not happen if they held more than a few city blocks. ISIS did take over the small town of Nawfaliya in February, but that is the extent of ISIS’ urban conquests in Libya.
In addition to highlighting the role that the ex-Saddamists are playing in ISIS’ military planning and logistics well beyond the borders of Iraq and Syria, the other major story here is about Abu Nabil’s executioners: al-Majlis Shura al-Mujahideen (The Mujahideen Shura Council or MSC) in Derna. The MSC was formed in December 2014 by inter alia the Abu Salim Martyrs’ Brigade (ASMB) and ASL. In other words, it seems that al-Qaeda is the leading edge of the anti-ISIS cause in eastern Libya.
The political debate will go on, between those who believe that order would have been restored to Libya by the West allowing Muammar el-Qaddafi to massacre the inhabitants of Benghazi, and those of us who see NATO’s failure as a lack of intervention in the aftermath of Colonel Qaddafi to stabilize the situation. But the importance of the spread of the intra-jihadist warfare between the Islamic State and al-Qaeda to the North African coast should not be overlooked. One means of point-scoring for the Salafi-jihadists is to bring off spectacular terrorist attacks in the West. The chances that al-Qaeda and/or ISIS have placed sleeper agents among the desperate waves of refugees making their way into Europe from Libya have to be reckoned at pretty near certain.
Update: A report for afrigatenews.net says that six former officers of the Saddam regime were dispatched to Sirte to oversee the creation of the Islamic State branch in Libya.
Update 2: The Pentagon reported that it killed “Abu Nabil, aka Wissam Najm Abd Zayd al-Zubaydi, an Iraqi national who was a longtime al-Qaeda operative and the senior ISIL leader in Libya,” in an airstrike in Libya on Nov. 13, 2015. The Defense Department’s statement added: “Reporting suggests he may also have been the spokesman in the February 2015 Coptic Christian execution video.”
Update 3: The Libya Herald reported on Nov. 15 that Abu Nabil was still alive. The Herald’s sources in Derna said that the two U.S. airstrikes on Wadi al-Khabtah and Wadi Bint, the two areas to the south of Derna city where ISIS has been holed up with its weapons stores since it was kicked out of Derna, failed to kill Abu Nabil, who was in Sirte at the time.
Update 4: The Pentagon released a statement on Dec. 7, 2015, saying that “Abu Nabil, a.k.a. Wissam Najm Abd Zayd az-Zubaydi, … is dead as a result of a US military airstrike in Libya undertaken on November 13.”
Update 5: The naming of ISIS’s offensive against Bin Jawad and the Sidra oil field in Libya on Jan. 4, 2016, “Ghazwa Shaykh Abu Mughira al-Qahtani,” and the Jan. 5, 2016, release of an official eulogy for al-Qahtani confirm that Abu Nabil and Abu Mughira are pseudonyms for the same man, al-Zubaydi, and appear to confirm also that he is dead. ISIS had first named al-Qahtani as their Libyan leader in Dabiq 11 on Sept. 9, 2015, and ISIS’s biography confirms that al-Qahtani had been their governor of Saladin Province, a position held by Abu Nabil. The biography also refutes the reporting that al-Zaydi spent time in prison with Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi: he was arrested in 2008 and imprisoned for a year-and-a-half, and was arrested again before being released in the jailbreak at Abu Ghraib in July 2013, according to ISIS.
Update 6: Pentagon statements and other reports had said that the American-accented man who “starred” in ISIS’s video showing the mass-murder of the Copts in February 2015—the man pictured right—was al-Qahtani/az-Zubaydi. This is not so. Az-Zubaydi has been seen in other video and audio output and this is not his voice.
 “Upon the Prophetic Methodology” was released by ISIS’s al-Furqan Media on 28 July 2014, and provided the first direct evidence of the massacre of Shi’i cadets who had been taken hostage as Camp Speicher fell to ISIS on 12 June 2014. Wissam al-Zubaydi is shown giving a pep-talk to ISIS troops as they head into Samarra the week before:
 A video appeared in March 2015 that showed Wissam al-Zubaydi conversing with the tribes in advance of the June 2014 offensive:
 ISIS’s Wilayat Saladin released a video on 11 July 2015, “And Kill Them Wherever You Overtake Them,” which showed scenes from the Speicher atrocity. Wissam al-Zubaydi appears twice. First, al-Zubaydi is glimpsed loading captives into trucks, which then drive to “execution” sites:
At a later point in the video, one of the Shi’i cadets claims he is Sunni and—in a manner now associated with Shaker al-Fahdawi (Abu Waheeb)—he was asked to prove it by conducting the Sunni rites. The cadet immediately goes wrong, and it is al-Zubaydi who steps in, grabs the young man, then murders him by shooting him in the back of the head. A section of a speech by Hamid al-Zawi (Abu Umar al-Baghdadi), the first emir of ad-Dawla (the State), is played over the scene.
Al-Zubaydi is shown murdering another half-dozen captives after this.